A comparison of pathologic outcomes of matched robotic and open partial nephrectomies

Matthew J. Mellon, Steven M. Lucas, Jennifer B J Kum, Liang Cheng, Chandru Sundaram

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Purpose: Open partial nephrectomy (OPN) and robotic partial nephrectomy (RPN) are widely utilized techniques for small renal masses. The lack of tactile feedback and limitations of laparoscopy may result in differences in the surgical specimen that may impact oncologic outcome. We present postoperative pathological outcomes data in a cohort of patients matched for nephrometry score, tumor size, gender and age. Materials and methods: We reviewed 81 patients who underwent partial nephrectomy between January 2003 and March 2010. Twenty-seven underwent RPN and 54 received OPN. Two OPN cases were matched for nephrometry score, tumor size, gender and age for each RPN. Postoperative pathological specimens were reviewed by a urologic pathologist regarding margin status, pathologic stage, histology, renal capsule violation, among other variables. Results: Sixty-two (76.5 %) patients were found to have renal cell carcinoma on final pathology. Frozen sectioning with tumor bed sampling was intra-operatively employed in 70 cases (86.4 %). The overall positive margin occurrence was 1 of 81 patients, which occurred during an RPN for a hilar tumor and converted to radical nephrectomy to achieve negative clinical margins. Additionally, 14.8 % of OPN patients had renal capsule violation as compared to 3.7 % of RPN cases (p = 0.34). Importantly, the mean distance to the proximal margin edge for RPN specimens (2.77 mm) was equivalent to OPN (3.01 mm), p = 0.46. Conclusion: When matched for nephrometry score, tumor size, gender and age, RPN produces similar pathological outcomes to OPN.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)381-385
Number of pages5
JournalInternational Urology and Nephrology
Volume45
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 2013

Fingerprint

Robotics
Nephrectomy
Neoplasms
Kidney
Capsules
Touch
Renal Cell Carcinoma
Laparoscopy
Histology

Keywords

  • Margin
  • Partial nephrectomy
  • Pathology

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Nephrology
  • Urology

Cite this

A comparison of pathologic outcomes of matched robotic and open partial nephrectomies. / Mellon, Matthew J.; Lucas, Steven M.; Kum, Jennifer B J; Cheng, Liang; Sundaram, Chandru.

In: International Urology and Nephrology, Vol. 45, No. 2, 04.2013, p. 381-385.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Mellon, Matthew J. ; Lucas, Steven M. ; Kum, Jennifer B J ; Cheng, Liang ; Sundaram, Chandru. / A comparison of pathologic outcomes of matched robotic and open partial nephrectomies. In: International Urology and Nephrology. 2013 ; Vol. 45, No. 2. pp. 381-385.
@article{b9dd41bfe08344c9b52c071b7b5b0759,
title = "A comparison of pathologic outcomes of matched robotic and open partial nephrectomies",
abstract = "Purpose: Open partial nephrectomy (OPN) and robotic partial nephrectomy (RPN) are widely utilized techniques for small renal masses. The lack of tactile feedback and limitations of laparoscopy may result in differences in the surgical specimen that may impact oncologic outcome. We present postoperative pathological outcomes data in a cohort of patients matched for nephrometry score, tumor size, gender and age. Materials and methods: We reviewed 81 patients who underwent partial nephrectomy between January 2003 and March 2010. Twenty-seven underwent RPN and 54 received OPN. Two OPN cases were matched for nephrometry score, tumor size, gender and age for each RPN. Postoperative pathological specimens were reviewed by a urologic pathologist regarding margin status, pathologic stage, histology, renal capsule violation, among other variables. Results: Sixty-two (76.5 {\%}) patients were found to have renal cell carcinoma on final pathology. Frozen sectioning with tumor bed sampling was intra-operatively employed in 70 cases (86.4 {\%}). The overall positive margin occurrence was 1 of 81 patients, which occurred during an RPN for a hilar tumor and converted to radical nephrectomy to achieve negative clinical margins. Additionally, 14.8 {\%} of OPN patients had renal capsule violation as compared to 3.7 {\%} of RPN cases (p = 0.34). Importantly, the mean distance to the proximal margin edge for RPN specimens (2.77 mm) was equivalent to OPN (3.01 mm), p = 0.46. Conclusion: When matched for nephrometry score, tumor size, gender and age, RPN produces similar pathological outcomes to OPN.",
keywords = "Margin, Partial nephrectomy, Pathology",
author = "Mellon, {Matthew J.} and Lucas, {Steven M.} and Kum, {Jennifer B J} and Liang Cheng and Chandru Sundaram",
year = "2013",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1007/s11255-013-0392-4",
language = "English",
volume = "45",
pages = "381--385",
journal = "International Urology and Nephrology",
issn = "0301-1623",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A comparison of pathologic outcomes of matched robotic and open partial nephrectomies

AU - Mellon, Matthew J.

AU - Lucas, Steven M.

AU - Kum, Jennifer B J

AU - Cheng, Liang

AU - Sundaram, Chandru

PY - 2013/4

Y1 - 2013/4

N2 - Purpose: Open partial nephrectomy (OPN) and robotic partial nephrectomy (RPN) are widely utilized techniques for small renal masses. The lack of tactile feedback and limitations of laparoscopy may result in differences in the surgical specimen that may impact oncologic outcome. We present postoperative pathological outcomes data in a cohort of patients matched for nephrometry score, tumor size, gender and age. Materials and methods: We reviewed 81 patients who underwent partial nephrectomy between January 2003 and March 2010. Twenty-seven underwent RPN and 54 received OPN. Two OPN cases were matched for nephrometry score, tumor size, gender and age for each RPN. Postoperative pathological specimens were reviewed by a urologic pathologist regarding margin status, pathologic stage, histology, renal capsule violation, among other variables. Results: Sixty-two (76.5 %) patients were found to have renal cell carcinoma on final pathology. Frozen sectioning with tumor bed sampling was intra-operatively employed in 70 cases (86.4 %). The overall positive margin occurrence was 1 of 81 patients, which occurred during an RPN for a hilar tumor and converted to radical nephrectomy to achieve negative clinical margins. Additionally, 14.8 % of OPN patients had renal capsule violation as compared to 3.7 % of RPN cases (p = 0.34). Importantly, the mean distance to the proximal margin edge for RPN specimens (2.77 mm) was equivalent to OPN (3.01 mm), p = 0.46. Conclusion: When matched for nephrometry score, tumor size, gender and age, RPN produces similar pathological outcomes to OPN.

AB - Purpose: Open partial nephrectomy (OPN) and robotic partial nephrectomy (RPN) are widely utilized techniques for small renal masses. The lack of tactile feedback and limitations of laparoscopy may result in differences in the surgical specimen that may impact oncologic outcome. We present postoperative pathological outcomes data in a cohort of patients matched for nephrometry score, tumor size, gender and age. Materials and methods: We reviewed 81 patients who underwent partial nephrectomy between January 2003 and March 2010. Twenty-seven underwent RPN and 54 received OPN. Two OPN cases were matched for nephrometry score, tumor size, gender and age for each RPN. Postoperative pathological specimens were reviewed by a urologic pathologist regarding margin status, pathologic stage, histology, renal capsule violation, among other variables. Results: Sixty-two (76.5 %) patients were found to have renal cell carcinoma on final pathology. Frozen sectioning with tumor bed sampling was intra-operatively employed in 70 cases (86.4 %). The overall positive margin occurrence was 1 of 81 patients, which occurred during an RPN for a hilar tumor and converted to radical nephrectomy to achieve negative clinical margins. Additionally, 14.8 % of OPN patients had renal capsule violation as compared to 3.7 % of RPN cases (p = 0.34). Importantly, the mean distance to the proximal margin edge for RPN specimens (2.77 mm) was equivalent to OPN (3.01 mm), p = 0.46. Conclusion: When matched for nephrometry score, tumor size, gender and age, RPN produces similar pathological outcomes to OPN.

KW - Margin

KW - Partial nephrectomy

KW - Pathology

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84880727514&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84880727514&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s11255-013-0392-4

DO - 10.1007/s11255-013-0392-4

M3 - Article

C2 - 23386247

AN - SCOPUS:84880727514

VL - 45

SP - 381

EP - 385

JO - International Urology and Nephrology

JF - International Urology and Nephrology

SN - 0301-1623

IS - 2

ER -