Accounting for Variance in Concussion Tolerance Between Individuals: Comparing Head Accelerations Between Concussed and Physically Matched Control Subjects

Steven Rowson, Eamon T. Campolettano, Stefan M. Duma, Brian Stemper, Alok Shah, Jaroslaw Harezlak, Larry Riggen, Jason P. Mihalik, Kevin M. Guskiewicz, Christopher Giza, Alison Brooks, Kenneth Cameron, Thomas McAllister, Steven P. Broglio, Michael McCrea

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Researchers have been collecting head impact data from instrumented football players to characterize the biomechanics of concussion for the past 15 years, yet the link between biomechanical input and clinical outcome is still not well understood. We have previously shown that even though concussive biomechanics might be unremarkable in large datasets of head impacts, the impacts causing injury are of high magnitude for the concussed individuals relative to their impact history. This finding suggests a need to account for differences in tolerance at the individual level. In this study, we identified control subjects for our concussed subjects who demonstrated traits we believed were correlated to factors thought to affect injury tolerance, including height, mass, age, race, and concussion history. A total of 502 college football players were instrumented with helmet-mounted accelerometer arrays and provided complete baseline assessment data, 44 of which sustained a total of 49 concussion. Biomechanical measures quantifying impact frequency and acceleration magnitude were compared between groups. On average, we found that concussed subjects experienced 93.8 more head impacts (p = 0.0031), 10.2 more high magnitude impacts (p = 0.0157), and 1.9 × greater risk-weighted exposure (p = 0.0175) than their physically matched controls. This finding provides further evidence that head impact data need to be considered at the individual level and that cohort wide assessments may be of little value in the context of concussion.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalAnnals of Biomedical Engineering
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

Biomechanics
Accelerometers

Keywords

  • Biomechanics
  • Brain injury
  • Football
  • Impact
  • Sensors
  • Threshold

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biomedical Engineering

Cite this

Accounting for Variance in Concussion Tolerance Between Individuals : Comparing Head Accelerations Between Concussed and Physically Matched Control Subjects. / Rowson, Steven; Campolettano, Eamon T.; Duma, Stefan M.; Stemper, Brian; Shah, Alok; Harezlak, Jaroslaw; Riggen, Larry; Mihalik, Jason P.; Guskiewicz, Kevin M.; Giza, Christopher; Brooks, Alison; Cameron, Kenneth; McAllister, Thomas; Broglio, Steven P.; McCrea, Michael.

In: Annals of Biomedical Engineering, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Rowson, S, Campolettano, ET, Duma, SM, Stemper, B, Shah, A, Harezlak, J, Riggen, L, Mihalik, JP, Guskiewicz, KM, Giza, C, Brooks, A, Cameron, K, McAllister, T, Broglio, SP & McCrea, M 2019, 'Accounting for Variance in Concussion Tolerance Between Individuals: Comparing Head Accelerations Between Concussed and Physically Matched Control Subjects', Annals of Biomedical Engineering. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-019-02329-7
Rowson, Steven ; Campolettano, Eamon T. ; Duma, Stefan M. ; Stemper, Brian ; Shah, Alok ; Harezlak, Jaroslaw ; Riggen, Larry ; Mihalik, Jason P. ; Guskiewicz, Kevin M. ; Giza, Christopher ; Brooks, Alison ; Cameron, Kenneth ; McAllister, Thomas ; Broglio, Steven P. ; McCrea, Michael. / Accounting for Variance in Concussion Tolerance Between Individuals : Comparing Head Accelerations Between Concussed and Physically Matched Control Subjects. In: Annals of Biomedical Engineering. 2019.
@article{ef139720b1554046a53106c4bcf9c12c,
title = "Accounting for Variance in Concussion Tolerance Between Individuals: Comparing Head Accelerations Between Concussed and Physically Matched Control Subjects",
abstract = "Researchers have been collecting head impact data from instrumented football players to characterize the biomechanics of concussion for the past 15 years, yet the link between biomechanical input and clinical outcome is still not well understood. We have previously shown that even though concussive biomechanics might be unremarkable in large datasets of head impacts, the impacts causing injury are of high magnitude for the concussed individuals relative to their impact history. This finding suggests a need to account for differences in tolerance at the individual level. In this study, we identified control subjects for our concussed subjects who demonstrated traits we believed were correlated to factors thought to affect injury tolerance, including height, mass, age, race, and concussion history. A total of 502 college football players were instrumented with helmet-mounted accelerometer arrays and provided complete baseline assessment data, 44 of which sustained a total of 49 concussion. Biomechanical measures quantifying impact frequency and acceleration magnitude were compared between groups. On average, we found that concussed subjects experienced 93.8 more head impacts (p = 0.0031), 10.2 more high magnitude impacts (p = 0.0157), and 1.9 × greater risk-weighted exposure (p = 0.0175) than their physically matched controls. This finding provides further evidence that head impact data need to be considered at the individual level and that cohort wide assessments may be of little value in the context of concussion.",
keywords = "Biomechanics, Brain injury, Football, Impact, Sensors, Threshold",
author = "Steven Rowson and Campolettano, {Eamon T.} and Duma, {Stefan M.} and Brian Stemper and Alok Shah and Jaroslaw Harezlak and Larry Riggen and Mihalik, {Jason P.} and Guskiewicz, {Kevin M.} and Christopher Giza and Alison Brooks and Kenneth Cameron and Thomas McAllister and Broglio, {Steven P.} and Michael McCrea",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s10439-019-02329-7",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Annals of Biomedical Engineering",
issn = "0090-6964",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Accounting for Variance in Concussion Tolerance Between Individuals

T2 - Comparing Head Accelerations Between Concussed and Physically Matched Control Subjects

AU - Rowson, Steven

AU - Campolettano, Eamon T.

AU - Duma, Stefan M.

AU - Stemper, Brian

AU - Shah, Alok

AU - Harezlak, Jaroslaw

AU - Riggen, Larry

AU - Mihalik, Jason P.

AU - Guskiewicz, Kevin M.

AU - Giza, Christopher

AU - Brooks, Alison

AU - Cameron, Kenneth

AU - McAllister, Thomas

AU - Broglio, Steven P.

AU - McCrea, Michael

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Researchers have been collecting head impact data from instrumented football players to characterize the biomechanics of concussion for the past 15 years, yet the link between biomechanical input and clinical outcome is still not well understood. We have previously shown that even though concussive biomechanics might be unremarkable in large datasets of head impacts, the impacts causing injury are of high magnitude for the concussed individuals relative to their impact history. This finding suggests a need to account for differences in tolerance at the individual level. In this study, we identified control subjects for our concussed subjects who demonstrated traits we believed were correlated to factors thought to affect injury tolerance, including height, mass, age, race, and concussion history. A total of 502 college football players were instrumented with helmet-mounted accelerometer arrays and provided complete baseline assessment data, 44 of which sustained a total of 49 concussion. Biomechanical measures quantifying impact frequency and acceleration magnitude were compared between groups. On average, we found that concussed subjects experienced 93.8 more head impacts (p = 0.0031), 10.2 more high magnitude impacts (p = 0.0157), and 1.9 × greater risk-weighted exposure (p = 0.0175) than their physically matched controls. This finding provides further evidence that head impact data need to be considered at the individual level and that cohort wide assessments may be of little value in the context of concussion.

AB - Researchers have been collecting head impact data from instrumented football players to characterize the biomechanics of concussion for the past 15 years, yet the link between biomechanical input and clinical outcome is still not well understood. We have previously shown that even though concussive biomechanics might be unremarkable in large datasets of head impacts, the impacts causing injury are of high magnitude for the concussed individuals relative to their impact history. This finding suggests a need to account for differences in tolerance at the individual level. In this study, we identified control subjects for our concussed subjects who demonstrated traits we believed were correlated to factors thought to affect injury tolerance, including height, mass, age, race, and concussion history. A total of 502 college football players were instrumented with helmet-mounted accelerometer arrays and provided complete baseline assessment data, 44 of which sustained a total of 49 concussion. Biomechanical measures quantifying impact frequency and acceleration magnitude were compared between groups. On average, we found that concussed subjects experienced 93.8 more head impacts (p = 0.0031), 10.2 more high magnitude impacts (p = 0.0157), and 1.9 × greater risk-weighted exposure (p = 0.0175) than their physically matched controls. This finding provides further evidence that head impact data need to be considered at the individual level and that cohort wide assessments may be of little value in the context of concussion.

KW - Biomechanics

KW - Brain injury

KW - Football

KW - Impact

KW - Sensors

KW - Threshold

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85069739111&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85069739111&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s10439-019-02329-7

DO - 10.1007/s10439-019-02329-7

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85069739111

JO - Annals of Biomedical Engineering

JF - Annals of Biomedical Engineering

SN - 0090-6964

ER -