Analysis of factors affecting the variability of a quantitative suspension bead array assay measuring IgG to multiple Plasmodium antigens

Itziar Ubillos, Ruth Aguilar, Hector Sanz, Alfons Jiménez, Marta Vidal, Aida Valmaseda, Yan Dong, Deepak Gaur, Chetan E. Chitnis, Sheetij Dutta, Evelina Angov, John J. Aponte, Joseph J. Campo, Clarissa Valim, Jaroslaw Harezlak, Carlota Dobaño

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Reducing variability of quantitative suspension array assays is key for multi-center and large sero-epidemiological studies. To maximize precision and robustness of an in-house IgG multiplex assay, we analyzed the effect of several conditions on variability to find the best combination. The following assay conditions were studied through a fractional factorial design: antigen-bead coupling (stock vs. several), sample predilution (stock vs. daily), temperature of incubation of sample with antigen-bead (22C vs. 37C), plate washing (manual vs. automatic) and operator expertise (expert vs. apprentice). IgG levels against seven P. falciparum antigens with heterogeneous immunogenicities were measured in test samples, in a positive control and in blanks. We assessed the variability and MFI quantification range associated to each combination of conditions, and their interactions, and evaluated the minimum number of samples and blank replicates to achieve good replicability. Results showed that antigen immunogenicity and sample seroreactivity defined the optimal dilution to assess the effect of assay conditions on variability. We found that a unique antigen-bead coupling, samples prediluted daily, incubation at 22C, and automatic washing, had lower variability. However, variability increased when performing several couplings and incubating at 22C vs. 37C. In addition, no effect of temperature was seen with a unique coupling. The expertise of the operator had no effect on assay variability but reduced the MFI quantification range. Finally, differences between sample replicates were minimal, and two blanks were sufficient to capture assay variability, as suggested by the constant Intraclass Correlation Coefficient of three and two blanks. To conclude, a single coupling was the variable that most consistently reduced assay variability, being clearly advisable. In addition, we suggest having more sample dilutions instead of replicates to increase the likelihood of sample MFIs falling in the linear part of the antigen-specific curve, thus increasing precision.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article numbere0199278
JournalPLoS One
Volume13
Issue number7
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 1 2018
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Plasmodium
Statistical Factor Analysis
Assays
Suspensions
Immunoglobulin G
antigens
Antigens
assays
sampling
Washing
Dilution
Apprentices
washing
Temperature
immune response
factor analysis
Epidemiologic Studies
serological surveys
temperature

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology(all)
  • Agricultural and Biological Sciences(all)

Cite this

Analysis of factors affecting the variability of a quantitative suspension bead array assay measuring IgG to multiple Plasmodium antigens. / Ubillos, Itziar; Aguilar, Ruth; Sanz, Hector; Jiménez, Alfons; Vidal, Marta; Valmaseda, Aida; Dong, Yan; Gaur, Deepak; Chitnis, Chetan E.; Dutta, Sheetij; Angov, Evelina; Aponte, John J.; Campo, Joseph J.; Valim, Clarissa; Harezlak, Jaroslaw; Dobaño, Carlota.

In: PLoS One, Vol. 13, No. 7, e0199278, 01.07.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Ubillos, I, Aguilar, R, Sanz, H, Jiménez, A, Vidal, M, Valmaseda, A, Dong, Y, Gaur, D, Chitnis, CE, Dutta, S, Angov, E, Aponte, JJ, Campo, JJ, Valim, C, Harezlak, J & Dobaño, C 2018, 'Analysis of factors affecting the variability of a quantitative suspension bead array assay measuring IgG to multiple Plasmodium antigens', PLoS One, vol. 13, no. 7, e0199278. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0199278
Ubillos, Itziar ; Aguilar, Ruth ; Sanz, Hector ; Jiménez, Alfons ; Vidal, Marta ; Valmaseda, Aida ; Dong, Yan ; Gaur, Deepak ; Chitnis, Chetan E. ; Dutta, Sheetij ; Angov, Evelina ; Aponte, John J. ; Campo, Joseph J. ; Valim, Clarissa ; Harezlak, Jaroslaw ; Dobaño, Carlota. / Analysis of factors affecting the variability of a quantitative suspension bead array assay measuring IgG to multiple Plasmodium antigens. In: PLoS One. 2018 ; Vol. 13, No. 7.
@article{2c2bb5e62d994cf2bc69b79bb1e6eec4,
title = "Analysis of factors affecting the variability of a quantitative suspension bead array assay measuring IgG to multiple Plasmodium antigens",
abstract = "Reducing variability of quantitative suspension array assays is key for multi-center and large sero-epidemiological studies. To maximize precision and robustness of an in-house IgG multiplex assay, we analyzed the effect of several conditions on variability to find the best combination. The following assay conditions were studied through a fractional factorial design: antigen-bead coupling (stock vs. several), sample predilution (stock vs. daily), temperature of incubation of sample with antigen-bead (22C vs. 37C), plate washing (manual vs. automatic) and operator expertise (expert vs. apprentice). IgG levels against seven P. falciparum antigens with heterogeneous immunogenicities were measured in test samples, in a positive control and in blanks. We assessed the variability and MFI quantification range associated to each combination of conditions, and their interactions, and evaluated the minimum number of samples and blank replicates to achieve good replicability. Results showed that antigen immunogenicity and sample seroreactivity defined the optimal dilution to assess the effect of assay conditions on variability. We found that a unique antigen-bead coupling, samples prediluted daily, incubation at 22C, and automatic washing, had lower variability. However, variability increased when performing several couplings and incubating at 22C vs. 37C. In addition, no effect of temperature was seen with a unique coupling. The expertise of the operator had no effect on assay variability but reduced the MFI quantification range. Finally, differences between sample replicates were minimal, and two blanks were sufficient to capture assay variability, as suggested by the constant Intraclass Correlation Coefficient of three and two blanks. To conclude, a single coupling was the variable that most consistently reduced assay variability, being clearly advisable. In addition, we suggest having more sample dilutions instead of replicates to increase the likelihood of sample MFIs falling in the linear part of the antigen-specific curve, thus increasing precision.",
author = "Itziar Ubillos and Ruth Aguilar and Hector Sanz and Alfons Jim{\'e}nez and Marta Vidal and Aida Valmaseda and Yan Dong and Deepak Gaur and Chitnis, {Chetan E.} and Sheetij Dutta and Evelina Angov and Aponte, {John J.} and Campo, {Joseph J.} and Clarissa Valim and Jaroslaw Harezlak and Carlota Doba{\~n}o",
year = "2018",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1371/journal.pone.0199278",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "13",
journal = "PLoS One",
issn = "1932-6203",
publisher = "Public Library of Science",
number = "7",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Analysis of factors affecting the variability of a quantitative suspension bead array assay measuring IgG to multiple Plasmodium antigens

AU - Ubillos, Itziar

AU - Aguilar, Ruth

AU - Sanz, Hector

AU - Jiménez, Alfons

AU - Vidal, Marta

AU - Valmaseda, Aida

AU - Dong, Yan

AU - Gaur, Deepak

AU - Chitnis, Chetan E.

AU - Dutta, Sheetij

AU - Angov, Evelina

AU - Aponte, John J.

AU - Campo, Joseph J.

AU - Valim, Clarissa

AU - Harezlak, Jaroslaw

AU - Dobaño, Carlota

PY - 2018/7/1

Y1 - 2018/7/1

N2 - Reducing variability of quantitative suspension array assays is key for multi-center and large sero-epidemiological studies. To maximize precision and robustness of an in-house IgG multiplex assay, we analyzed the effect of several conditions on variability to find the best combination. The following assay conditions were studied through a fractional factorial design: antigen-bead coupling (stock vs. several), sample predilution (stock vs. daily), temperature of incubation of sample with antigen-bead (22C vs. 37C), plate washing (manual vs. automatic) and operator expertise (expert vs. apprentice). IgG levels against seven P. falciparum antigens with heterogeneous immunogenicities were measured in test samples, in a positive control and in blanks. We assessed the variability and MFI quantification range associated to each combination of conditions, and their interactions, and evaluated the minimum number of samples and blank replicates to achieve good replicability. Results showed that antigen immunogenicity and sample seroreactivity defined the optimal dilution to assess the effect of assay conditions on variability. We found that a unique antigen-bead coupling, samples prediluted daily, incubation at 22C, and automatic washing, had lower variability. However, variability increased when performing several couplings and incubating at 22C vs. 37C. In addition, no effect of temperature was seen with a unique coupling. The expertise of the operator had no effect on assay variability but reduced the MFI quantification range. Finally, differences between sample replicates were minimal, and two blanks were sufficient to capture assay variability, as suggested by the constant Intraclass Correlation Coefficient of three and two blanks. To conclude, a single coupling was the variable that most consistently reduced assay variability, being clearly advisable. In addition, we suggest having more sample dilutions instead of replicates to increase the likelihood of sample MFIs falling in the linear part of the antigen-specific curve, thus increasing precision.

AB - Reducing variability of quantitative suspension array assays is key for multi-center and large sero-epidemiological studies. To maximize precision and robustness of an in-house IgG multiplex assay, we analyzed the effect of several conditions on variability to find the best combination. The following assay conditions were studied through a fractional factorial design: antigen-bead coupling (stock vs. several), sample predilution (stock vs. daily), temperature of incubation of sample with antigen-bead (22C vs. 37C), plate washing (manual vs. automatic) and operator expertise (expert vs. apprentice). IgG levels against seven P. falciparum antigens with heterogeneous immunogenicities were measured in test samples, in a positive control and in blanks. We assessed the variability and MFI quantification range associated to each combination of conditions, and their interactions, and evaluated the minimum number of samples and blank replicates to achieve good replicability. Results showed that antigen immunogenicity and sample seroreactivity defined the optimal dilution to assess the effect of assay conditions on variability. We found that a unique antigen-bead coupling, samples prediluted daily, incubation at 22C, and automatic washing, had lower variability. However, variability increased when performing several couplings and incubating at 22C vs. 37C. In addition, no effect of temperature was seen with a unique coupling. The expertise of the operator had no effect on assay variability but reduced the MFI quantification range. Finally, differences between sample replicates were minimal, and two blanks were sufficient to capture assay variability, as suggested by the constant Intraclass Correlation Coefficient of three and two blanks. To conclude, a single coupling was the variable that most consistently reduced assay variability, being clearly advisable. In addition, we suggest having more sample dilutions instead of replicates to increase the likelihood of sample MFIs falling in the linear part of the antigen-specific curve, thus increasing precision.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85049356768&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85049356768&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1371/journal.pone.0199278

DO - 10.1371/journal.pone.0199278

M3 - Article

C2 - 29966018

AN - SCOPUS:85049356768

VL - 13

JO - PLoS One

JF - PLoS One

SN - 1932-6203

IS - 7

M1 - e0199278

ER -