Ascertainment bias in turner syndrome

new insights from girls who were diagnosed incidentally in prenatal life

Daniel F. Gunther, Erica Eugster, Anthony J. Zagar, Constance G. Bryant, Marsha L. Davenport, Charmian A. Quigley

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

45 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective. To evaluate differences in phenotype and other clinical features between patients who have Turner syndrome diagnosed incidentally (on the basis of a prenatal karyotype performed for reasons unrelated to suspicion of Turner syndrome, eg, advanced maternal age) or traditionally (on the basis of either a prenatal karyotype performed for abnormal ultrasound findings or a postnatal karyotype performed for clinical findings suggesting Turner syndrome). Methods. Analysis was performed on baseline data from 88 girls, aged 9 months to 4 years, who were randomized into a multicenter growth hormone intervention trial. Baseline information included a detailed medical history (especially of cardiac and renal anomalies), examination for presence of phenotypic features characteristic of Turner syndrome, length or height (depending on age) expressed as a standard deviation score, and weight standard deviation score. Patients were classified to either the "incidental" (N = 16) or the "traditional" (N = 72) diagnosis group as described above. Results. The incidental group had significantly fewer total phenotypic features of Turner syndrome than the traditional group (3.6 ± 2.9 vs 6.7 ± 2.9). When subgrouped by karyotype, the proportion of patients who manifested phenotypic features was greatest in patients with a 45,X nonmosaic karyotype, lowest in the patients with 45,X/46,XX mosaicism, and intermediate in those with "other" karyotypes. Fewer congenital cardiac defects were observed in the incidental group (31%) compared with the traditional group (64%), but there was no difference between the groups in the prevalence of renal defects. Karyotype distribution differed significantly between the traditional and incidental groups: 74% versus 19% had the nonmosaic 45,X karyotype in the traditional group and 7% versus 56% had the mosaic 45,X/46,XX karyotype. Conclusions. Patients whose Turner syndrome was diagnosed incidentally had significantly fewer phenotypic features and cardiac defects, as well as a greater proportion of mosaic karyotypes, compared with patients whose Turner syndrome was diagnosed clinically. These results support the theory that significant ascertainment bias exists in our understanding Turner syndrome, with important implications for prenatal counseling.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)640-644
Number of pages5
JournalPediatrics
Volume114
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 2004

Fingerprint

Turner Syndrome
Karyotype
Abnormal Karyotype
Kidney
Mosaicism
Maternal Age
Growth Hormone
Counseling
Phenotype
Weights and Measures

Keywords

  • Amniocentesis
  • Ascertainment bias
  • Cardiac anomalies
  • Karyotype
  • Phenotype
  • Prenatal counseling
  • Prenatal diagnosis
  • Turner syndrome

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Pediatrics, Perinatology, and Child Health

Cite this

Ascertainment bias in turner syndrome : new insights from girls who were diagnosed incidentally in prenatal life. / Gunther, Daniel F.; Eugster, Erica; Zagar, Anthony J.; Bryant, Constance G.; Davenport, Marsha L.; Quigley, Charmian A.

In: Pediatrics, Vol. 114, No. 3, 09.2004, p. 640-644.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Gunther, Daniel F. ; Eugster, Erica ; Zagar, Anthony J. ; Bryant, Constance G. ; Davenport, Marsha L. ; Quigley, Charmian A. / Ascertainment bias in turner syndrome : new insights from girls who were diagnosed incidentally in prenatal life. In: Pediatrics. 2004 ; Vol. 114, No. 3. pp. 640-644.
@article{21bf48bca49c4044a9dfa4e8c494d45e,
title = "Ascertainment bias in turner syndrome: new insights from girls who were diagnosed incidentally in prenatal life",
abstract = "Objective. To evaluate differences in phenotype and other clinical features between patients who have Turner syndrome diagnosed incidentally (on the basis of a prenatal karyotype performed for reasons unrelated to suspicion of Turner syndrome, eg, advanced maternal age) or traditionally (on the basis of either a prenatal karyotype performed for abnormal ultrasound findings or a postnatal karyotype performed for clinical findings suggesting Turner syndrome). Methods. Analysis was performed on baseline data from 88 girls, aged 9 months to 4 years, who were randomized into a multicenter growth hormone intervention trial. Baseline information included a detailed medical history (especially of cardiac and renal anomalies), examination for presence of phenotypic features characteristic of Turner syndrome, length or height (depending on age) expressed as a standard deviation score, and weight standard deviation score. Patients were classified to either the {"}incidental{"} (N = 16) or the {"}traditional{"} (N = 72) diagnosis group as described above. Results. The incidental group had significantly fewer total phenotypic features of Turner syndrome than the traditional group (3.6 ± 2.9 vs 6.7 ± 2.9). When subgrouped by karyotype, the proportion of patients who manifested phenotypic features was greatest in patients with a 45,X nonmosaic karyotype, lowest in the patients with 45,X/46,XX mosaicism, and intermediate in those with {"}other{"} karyotypes. Fewer congenital cardiac defects were observed in the incidental group (31{\%}) compared with the traditional group (64{\%}), but there was no difference between the groups in the prevalence of renal defects. Karyotype distribution differed significantly between the traditional and incidental groups: 74{\%} versus 19{\%} had the nonmosaic 45,X karyotype in the traditional group and 7{\%} versus 56{\%} had the mosaic 45,X/46,XX karyotype. Conclusions. Patients whose Turner syndrome was diagnosed incidentally had significantly fewer phenotypic features and cardiac defects, as well as a greater proportion of mosaic karyotypes, compared with patients whose Turner syndrome was diagnosed clinically. These results support the theory that significant ascertainment bias exists in our understanding Turner syndrome, with important implications for prenatal counseling.",
keywords = "Amniocentesis, Ascertainment bias, Cardiac anomalies, Karyotype, Phenotype, Prenatal counseling, Prenatal diagnosis, Turner syndrome",
author = "Gunther, {Daniel F.} and Erica Eugster and Zagar, {Anthony J.} and Bryant, {Constance G.} and Davenport, {Marsha L.} and Quigley, {Charmian A.}",
year = "2004",
month = "9",
doi = "10.1542/peds.2003-1122-L",
language = "English",
volume = "114",
pages = "640--644",
journal = "Pediatrics",
issn = "0031-4005",
publisher = "American Academy of Pediatrics",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Ascertainment bias in turner syndrome

T2 - new insights from girls who were diagnosed incidentally in prenatal life

AU - Gunther, Daniel F.

AU - Eugster, Erica

AU - Zagar, Anthony J.

AU - Bryant, Constance G.

AU - Davenport, Marsha L.

AU - Quigley, Charmian A.

PY - 2004/9

Y1 - 2004/9

N2 - Objective. To evaluate differences in phenotype and other clinical features between patients who have Turner syndrome diagnosed incidentally (on the basis of a prenatal karyotype performed for reasons unrelated to suspicion of Turner syndrome, eg, advanced maternal age) or traditionally (on the basis of either a prenatal karyotype performed for abnormal ultrasound findings or a postnatal karyotype performed for clinical findings suggesting Turner syndrome). Methods. Analysis was performed on baseline data from 88 girls, aged 9 months to 4 years, who were randomized into a multicenter growth hormone intervention trial. Baseline information included a detailed medical history (especially of cardiac and renal anomalies), examination for presence of phenotypic features characteristic of Turner syndrome, length or height (depending on age) expressed as a standard deviation score, and weight standard deviation score. Patients were classified to either the "incidental" (N = 16) or the "traditional" (N = 72) diagnosis group as described above. Results. The incidental group had significantly fewer total phenotypic features of Turner syndrome than the traditional group (3.6 ± 2.9 vs 6.7 ± 2.9). When subgrouped by karyotype, the proportion of patients who manifested phenotypic features was greatest in patients with a 45,X nonmosaic karyotype, lowest in the patients with 45,X/46,XX mosaicism, and intermediate in those with "other" karyotypes. Fewer congenital cardiac defects were observed in the incidental group (31%) compared with the traditional group (64%), but there was no difference between the groups in the prevalence of renal defects. Karyotype distribution differed significantly between the traditional and incidental groups: 74% versus 19% had the nonmosaic 45,X karyotype in the traditional group and 7% versus 56% had the mosaic 45,X/46,XX karyotype. Conclusions. Patients whose Turner syndrome was diagnosed incidentally had significantly fewer phenotypic features and cardiac defects, as well as a greater proportion of mosaic karyotypes, compared with patients whose Turner syndrome was diagnosed clinically. These results support the theory that significant ascertainment bias exists in our understanding Turner syndrome, with important implications for prenatal counseling.

AB - Objective. To evaluate differences in phenotype and other clinical features between patients who have Turner syndrome diagnosed incidentally (on the basis of a prenatal karyotype performed for reasons unrelated to suspicion of Turner syndrome, eg, advanced maternal age) or traditionally (on the basis of either a prenatal karyotype performed for abnormal ultrasound findings or a postnatal karyotype performed for clinical findings suggesting Turner syndrome). Methods. Analysis was performed on baseline data from 88 girls, aged 9 months to 4 years, who were randomized into a multicenter growth hormone intervention trial. Baseline information included a detailed medical history (especially of cardiac and renal anomalies), examination for presence of phenotypic features characteristic of Turner syndrome, length or height (depending on age) expressed as a standard deviation score, and weight standard deviation score. Patients were classified to either the "incidental" (N = 16) or the "traditional" (N = 72) diagnosis group as described above. Results. The incidental group had significantly fewer total phenotypic features of Turner syndrome than the traditional group (3.6 ± 2.9 vs 6.7 ± 2.9). When subgrouped by karyotype, the proportion of patients who manifested phenotypic features was greatest in patients with a 45,X nonmosaic karyotype, lowest in the patients with 45,X/46,XX mosaicism, and intermediate in those with "other" karyotypes. Fewer congenital cardiac defects were observed in the incidental group (31%) compared with the traditional group (64%), but there was no difference between the groups in the prevalence of renal defects. Karyotype distribution differed significantly between the traditional and incidental groups: 74% versus 19% had the nonmosaic 45,X karyotype in the traditional group and 7% versus 56% had the mosaic 45,X/46,XX karyotype. Conclusions. Patients whose Turner syndrome was diagnosed incidentally had significantly fewer phenotypic features and cardiac defects, as well as a greater proportion of mosaic karyotypes, compared with patients whose Turner syndrome was diagnosed clinically. These results support the theory that significant ascertainment bias exists in our understanding Turner syndrome, with important implications for prenatal counseling.

KW - Amniocentesis

KW - Ascertainment bias

KW - Cardiac anomalies

KW - Karyotype

KW - Phenotype

KW - Prenatal counseling

KW - Prenatal diagnosis

KW - Turner syndrome

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=16544369724&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=16544369724&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1542/peds.2003-1122-L

DO - 10.1542/peds.2003-1122-L

M3 - Article

VL - 114

SP - 640

EP - 644

JO - Pediatrics

JF - Pediatrics

SN - 0031-4005

IS - 3

ER -