Comparative call characteristics in the anuran subgenus nenirana

Michael Lannoo, Rochelle M. Stiles, Daniel Saenz, Toby J. Hibbitts

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

It is important that species descriptions be accurate. This is especially true with threatened and endangered species, where the scientific literature provides context for species identification and management decisions. In 1953, Bragg documented the advertisement calls of both Southern Crawfish Frogs (Lithobates a. areolatus) and Northern Crawfish Frogs (L. a. circulosus) and concluded L. a. areolatus have lower frequency calls. One of us (M.J.L.) has long felt this observation was incorrect, because adult L. a. areolatus are smaller than L. a. circulosus, and anurans with smaller body sizes tend to produce higher, not lower, frequency calls. Bragg's observations are not only the sole comparative assessment of advertisement call characteristics of L. areolatus in the primary literature, but also represent the only assessment of the advertisement calls of any of the four species comprising the subgenus Nenirana, which consists of threatened and endangered Gopher Frogs (L. capito and L. sevosus) and Pickerel Frogs (L. palustris). Given this dearth of information, the reliability of this information, and the conservation concerns surrounding this group, we felt it was necessary to reassess the advertisement calls of Crawfish Frogs and give them context by describing the calls of the Nenirana species L. capito and L. palustris. Our data revise Bragg's conclusions, but just as importantly, we show that the call characteristics of L. capito and L. palustris are similar by having long calls with long interpulse intervals, while both subspecies of L. areolatus have shorter calls with less interpulse separation. These results do not align with morphological and phylogenetic clustering within the Nenirana, but are consistent with call character displacement within this group. Additional data will be necessary to test this inference.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)575-579
Number of pages5
JournalCopeia
Volume106
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 1 2018

Fingerprint

frog
frogs
crayfish
Rana palustris
Lithobates
character displacement
threatened species
endangered species
body size
subspecies
phylogeny
phylogenetics
advertisement
testing

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics
  • Aquatic Science
  • Animal Science and Zoology

Cite this

Comparative call characteristics in the anuran subgenus nenirana. / Lannoo, Michael; Stiles, Rochelle M.; Saenz, Daniel; Hibbitts, Toby J.

In: Copeia, Vol. 106, No. 4, 01.12.2018, p. 575-579.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Lannoo, M, Stiles, RM, Saenz, D & Hibbitts, TJ 2018, 'Comparative call characteristics in the anuran subgenus nenirana', Copeia, vol. 106, no. 4, pp. 575-579. https://doi.org/10.1643/CE-18-019
Lannoo, Michael ; Stiles, Rochelle M. ; Saenz, Daniel ; Hibbitts, Toby J. / Comparative call characteristics in the anuran subgenus nenirana. In: Copeia. 2018 ; Vol. 106, No. 4. pp. 575-579.
@article{4b174d0b8de544c4b9273347364c196c,
title = "Comparative call characteristics in the anuran subgenus nenirana",
abstract = "It is important that species descriptions be accurate. This is especially true with threatened and endangered species, where the scientific literature provides context for species identification and management decisions. In 1953, Bragg documented the advertisement calls of both Southern Crawfish Frogs (Lithobates a. areolatus) and Northern Crawfish Frogs (L. a. circulosus) and concluded L. a. areolatus have lower frequency calls. One of us (M.J.L.) has long felt this observation was incorrect, because adult L. a. areolatus are smaller than L. a. circulosus, and anurans with smaller body sizes tend to produce higher, not lower, frequency calls. Bragg's observations are not only the sole comparative assessment of advertisement call characteristics of L. areolatus in the primary literature, but also represent the only assessment of the advertisement calls of any of the four species comprising the subgenus Nenirana, which consists of threatened and endangered Gopher Frogs (L. capito and L. sevosus) and Pickerel Frogs (L. palustris). Given this dearth of information, the reliability of this information, and the conservation concerns surrounding this group, we felt it was necessary to reassess the advertisement calls of Crawfish Frogs and give them context by describing the calls of the Nenirana species L. capito and L. palustris. Our data revise Bragg's conclusions, but just as importantly, we show that the call characteristics of L. capito and L. palustris are similar by having long calls with long interpulse intervals, while both subspecies of L. areolatus have shorter calls with less interpulse separation. These results do not align with morphological and phylogenetic clustering within the Nenirana, but are consistent with call character displacement within this group. Additional data will be necessary to test this inference.",
author = "Michael Lannoo and Stiles, {Rochelle M.} and Daniel Saenz and Hibbitts, {Toby J.}",
year = "2018",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1643/CE-18-019",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "106",
pages = "575--579",
journal = "Copeia",
issn = "0045-8511",
publisher = "American Society of Ichthyologists and Herpetologists",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparative call characteristics in the anuran subgenus nenirana

AU - Lannoo, Michael

AU - Stiles, Rochelle M.

AU - Saenz, Daniel

AU - Hibbitts, Toby J.

PY - 2018/12/1

Y1 - 2018/12/1

N2 - It is important that species descriptions be accurate. This is especially true with threatened and endangered species, where the scientific literature provides context for species identification and management decisions. In 1953, Bragg documented the advertisement calls of both Southern Crawfish Frogs (Lithobates a. areolatus) and Northern Crawfish Frogs (L. a. circulosus) and concluded L. a. areolatus have lower frequency calls. One of us (M.J.L.) has long felt this observation was incorrect, because adult L. a. areolatus are smaller than L. a. circulosus, and anurans with smaller body sizes tend to produce higher, not lower, frequency calls. Bragg's observations are not only the sole comparative assessment of advertisement call characteristics of L. areolatus in the primary literature, but also represent the only assessment of the advertisement calls of any of the four species comprising the subgenus Nenirana, which consists of threatened and endangered Gopher Frogs (L. capito and L. sevosus) and Pickerel Frogs (L. palustris). Given this dearth of information, the reliability of this information, and the conservation concerns surrounding this group, we felt it was necessary to reassess the advertisement calls of Crawfish Frogs and give them context by describing the calls of the Nenirana species L. capito and L. palustris. Our data revise Bragg's conclusions, but just as importantly, we show that the call characteristics of L. capito and L. palustris are similar by having long calls with long interpulse intervals, while both subspecies of L. areolatus have shorter calls with less interpulse separation. These results do not align with morphological and phylogenetic clustering within the Nenirana, but are consistent with call character displacement within this group. Additional data will be necessary to test this inference.

AB - It is important that species descriptions be accurate. This is especially true with threatened and endangered species, where the scientific literature provides context for species identification and management decisions. In 1953, Bragg documented the advertisement calls of both Southern Crawfish Frogs (Lithobates a. areolatus) and Northern Crawfish Frogs (L. a. circulosus) and concluded L. a. areolatus have lower frequency calls. One of us (M.J.L.) has long felt this observation was incorrect, because adult L. a. areolatus are smaller than L. a. circulosus, and anurans with smaller body sizes tend to produce higher, not lower, frequency calls. Bragg's observations are not only the sole comparative assessment of advertisement call characteristics of L. areolatus in the primary literature, but also represent the only assessment of the advertisement calls of any of the four species comprising the subgenus Nenirana, which consists of threatened and endangered Gopher Frogs (L. capito and L. sevosus) and Pickerel Frogs (L. palustris). Given this dearth of information, the reliability of this information, and the conservation concerns surrounding this group, we felt it was necessary to reassess the advertisement calls of Crawfish Frogs and give them context by describing the calls of the Nenirana species L. capito and L. palustris. Our data revise Bragg's conclusions, but just as importantly, we show that the call characteristics of L. capito and L. palustris are similar by having long calls with long interpulse intervals, while both subspecies of L. areolatus have shorter calls with less interpulse separation. These results do not align with morphological and phylogenetic clustering within the Nenirana, but are consistent with call character displacement within this group. Additional data will be necessary to test this inference.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85055290041&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85055290041&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1643/CE-18-019

DO - 10.1643/CE-18-019

M3 - Article

VL - 106

SP - 575

EP - 579

JO - Copeia

JF - Copeia

SN - 0045-8511

IS - 4

ER -