Comparison of ThinPrep and cytospin preparations in the evaluation of exfoliative cytology specimens

Tarik M. Elsheikh, Joseph L. Kirkpatrick, Howard H. Wu

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

39 Scopus citations

Abstract

BACKGROUND. There exists limited literature comparing ThinPrep (TP) with conventional cytospins (CS) in nongynecologic specimens. METHODS. The differences between TP and CS were evaluated for a variety of parameters including cellularity, cytologic morphology, specimen preparation, screening time, laboratory cost effectiveness, cytologist preference, and impact on final diagnosis. Eighty-eight cases including 38 urine, 13 respiratory, and 37 body fluids were prepared simultaneously. RESULTS. TP and CS demonstrated similar cellular yield in the majority of cases. Cytologists preferred TP in 63 (71.6%) and CS in 6 (6.8%) cases; whereas they indicated no preference in 19 (21.6%) cases. Of 14 abnormal cytologies, a more definitive diagnosis of malignancy was rendered by TP in 6 (42.9%) and by CS in 2 (14.3%) cases. TP demonstrated better nuclear chromatin morphology and more uniform distribution of cells. CS showed larger-sized clusters with better preservation of their architecture compared with smaller-sized clusters and significant shrinkage of cell size in TP. CONCLUSIONS. TP was preferred over CS in the majority of cases by both cytotechnologists and pathologists. Cellularity, screening time, and specimen preparation were comparable, although the latter was easier to standardize in TP. In abnormal cases, TP was found to be 3 times more helpful than CS in rendering a definitive diagnosis of malignancy. TP, however, was associated with certain artifacts that cytologists must become familiar with when examining such preparations. Although TP was superior to CS in most cases, the application of both methods may be helpful in selected cases in which the TP diagnosis is not conclusive. Finally, TP was found to be more cost effective than CS.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)144-149
Number of pages6
JournalCancer
Volume108
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 25 2006

    Fingerprint

Keywords

  • Cytospin
  • Exfoliative cytology
  • Fluids
  • Nongynecologic cytology
  • Respiratory
  • ThinPrep

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Oncology
  • Cancer Research

Cite this