Continuing decline in service delivery for family physicians: Is the malpractice crisis playing a role?

Nir Menachemi, Robert G. Brooks, Art Clawson, Curtis Stine, Les Beitsch

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

PURPOSE: This study was conducted to monitor trends in the reduction and elimination of services offered by family physicians. In addition, we examined whether the malpractice situation may be influencing these trends. METHODS: We surveyed all family physicians in rural Florida and an equal number of randomly selected, urban, family physicians in the state. We examined changes in professional liability insurance (PLI) premiums, and changes in services offered, practice satisfaction, and future practice plans. RESULTS: Overall, 308 (42.1%) family physicians responded. Results suggest that 60.3% of them reduced or eliminated services in the last year. Specifically, almost two thirds of respondents had eliminated hospital-based surgeries (65.2%) and vaginal deliveries (64.5%). Furthermore, endoscopies were decreased or eliminated by 69% of survey participants, and coverage of emergency departments and nursing homes was reduced or eliminated by 64.1% and 56.4% of respondents, respectively. Increases in the PLI averaged 78.2%. Overall increases in the PLI were significantly related to a decrease or elimination of services offered by family physicians. Dissatisfaction with practice was relatively high (36.8%) and was associated with both the reduction of services and an intention to leave practice within 2 years. No major differences in these trends were noted between rural and urban family physicians. CONCLUSIONS: Access to care provided by rural and urban family physicians in Florida is being hampered by the malpractice situation and other factors. Policymakers may need to focus on these factors in an effort to relieve additional barriers to care for vulnerable populations.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)39-45
Number of pages7
JournalQuality Management in Health Care
Volume15
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2006
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

family physician
Malpractice
Family Physicians
Liability Insurance
liability insurance
Legal Liability
trend
Emergency Nursing
Vulnerable Populations
nursing home
Nursing Homes
premium
Insurance
surgery
Endoscopy
Hospital Emergency Service
coverage
Surveys and Questionnaires

Keywords

  • Primary care
  • Professional liability insurance premiums
  • Service delivery

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Leadership and Management
  • Health(social science)
  • Health Policy
  • Care Planning

Cite this

Continuing decline in service delivery for family physicians : Is the malpractice crisis playing a role? / Menachemi, Nir; Brooks, Robert G.; Clawson, Art; Stine, Curtis; Beitsch, Les.

In: Quality Management in Health Care, Vol. 15, No. 1, 01.01.2006, p. 39-45.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Menachemi, Nir ; Brooks, Robert G. ; Clawson, Art ; Stine, Curtis ; Beitsch, Les. / Continuing decline in service delivery for family physicians : Is the malpractice crisis playing a role?. In: Quality Management in Health Care. 2006 ; Vol. 15, No. 1. pp. 39-45.
@article{f87e9383b75f46878a125b42d0333e4d,
title = "Continuing decline in service delivery for family physicians: Is the malpractice crisis playing a role?",
abstract = "PURPOSE: This study was conducted to monitor trends in the reduction and elimination of services offered by family physicians. In addition, we examined whether the malpractice situation may be influencing these trends. METHODS: We surveyed all family physicians in rural Florida and an equal number of randomly selected, urban, family physicians in the state. We examined changes in professional liability insurance (PLI) premiums, and changes in services offered, practice satisfaction, and future practice plans. RESULTS: Overall, 308 (42.1{\%}) family physicians responded. Results suggest that 60.3{\%} of them reduced or eliminated services in the last year. Specifically, almost two thirds of respondents had eliminated hospital-based surgeries (65.2{\%}) and vaginal deliveries (64.5{\%}). Furthermore, endoscopies were decreased or eliminated by 69{\%} of survey participants, and coverage of emergency departments and nursing homes was reduced or eliminated by 64.1{\%} and 56.4{\%} of respondents, respectively. Increases in the PLI averaged 78.2{\%}. Overall increases in the PLI were significantly related to a decrease or elimination of services offered by family physicians. Dissatisfaction with practice was relatively high (36.8{\%}) and was associated with both the reduction of services and an intention to leave practice within 2 years. No major differences in these trends were noted between rural and urban family physicians. CONCLUSIONS: Access to care provided by rural and urban family physicians in Florida is being hampered by the malpractice situation and other factors. Policymakers may need to focus on these factors in an effort to relieve additional barriers to care for vulnerable populations.",
keywords = "Primary care, Professional liability insurance premiums, Service delivery",
author = "Nir Menachemi and Brooks, {Robert G.} and Art Clawson and Curtis Stine and Les Beitsch",
year = "2006",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1097/00019514-200601000-00005",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "15",
pages = "39--45",
journal = "Quality Management in Health Care",
issn = "1063-8628",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Continuing decline in service delivery for family physicians

T2 - Is the malpractice crisis playing a role?

AU - Menachemi, Nir

AU - Brooks, Robert G.

AU - Clawson, Art

AU - Stine, Curtis

AU - Beitsch, Les

PY - 2006/1/1

Y1 - 2006/1/1

N2 - PURPOSE: This study was conducted to monitor trends in the reduction and elimination of services offered by family physicians. In addition, we examined whether the malpractice situation may be influencing these trends. METHODS: We surveyed all family physicians in rural Florida and an equal number of randomly selected, urban, family physicians in the state. We examined changes in professional liability insurance (PLI) premiums, and changes in services offered, practice satisfaction, and future practice plans. RESULTS: Overall, 308 (42.1%) family physicians responded. Results suggest that 60.3% of them reduced or eliminated services in the last year. Specifically, almost two thirds of respondents had eliminated hospital-based surgeries (65.2%) and vaginal deliveries (64.5%). Furthermore, endoscopies were decreased or eliminated by 69% of survey participants, and coverage of emergency departments and nursing homes was reduced or eliminated by 64.1% and 56.4% of respondents, respectively. Increases in the PLI averaged 78.2%. Overall increases in the PLI were significantly related to a decrease or elimination of services offered by family physicians. Dissatisfaction with practice was relatively high (36.8%) and was associated with both the reduction of services and an intention to leave practice within 2 years. No major differences in these trends were noted between rural and urban family physicians. CONCLUSIONS: Access to care provided by rural and urban family physicians in Florida is being hampered by the malpractice situation and other factors. Policymakers may need to focus on these factors in an effort to relieve additional barriers to care for vulnerable populations.

AB - PURPOSE: This study was conducted to monitor trends in the reduction and elimination of services offered by family physicians. In addition, we examined whether the malpractice situation may be influencing these trends. METHODS: We surveyed all family physicians in rural Florida and an equal number of randomly selected, urban, family physicians in the state. We examined changes in professional liability insurance (PLI) premiums, and changes in services offered, practice satisfaction, and future practice plans. RESULTS: Overall, 308 (42.1%) family physicians responded. Results suggest that 60.3% of them reduced or eliminated services in the last year. Specifically, almost two thirds of respondents had eliminated hospital-based surgeries (65.2%) and vaginal deliveries (64.5%). Furthermore, endoscopies were decreased or eliminated by 69% of survey participants, and coverage of emergency departments and nursing homes was reduced or eliminated by 64.1% and 56.4% of respondents, respectively. Increases in the PLI averaged 78.2%. Overall increases in the PLI were significantly related to a decrease or elimination of services offered by family physicians. Dissatisfaction with practice was relatively high (36.8%) and was associated with both the reduction of services and an intention to leave practice within 2 years. No major differences in these trends were noted between rural and urban family physicians. CONCLUSIONS: Access to care provided by rural and urban family physicians in Florida is being hampered by the malpractice situation and other factors. Policymakers may need to focus on these factors in an effort to relieve additional barriers to care for vulnerable populations.

KW - Primary care

KW - Professional liability insurance premiums

KW - Service delivery

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33644932622&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33644932622&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1097/00019514-200601000-00005

DO - 10.1097/00019514-200601000-00005

M3 - Article

C2 - 16456479

AN - SCOPUS:33644932622

VL - 15

SP - 39

EP - 45

JO - Quality Management in Health Care

JF - Quality Management in Health Care

SN - 1063-8628

IS - 1

ER -