Longitudinal growth changes of the cranial base from puberty to adulthood- A comparison of different superimposition methods

Zuleyha Mirzen Arat, Hakan Turkkahraman, Jeryl D. English, Ronald L. Gallerano, Jim C. Boley

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective: To investigate the stability of cranial reference landmarks from puberty through adulthood and to compare the displacement of these landmarks among the superimposition methods of Björk, Ricketts, Steiner, and the proposed tuberculum sella-wing (T-W) reference line. Materials and Methods: The sample consisted of serial lateral cephalometric radiographs of 30 Class II division 1 patients taken at the pretreatment (T1; mean age, 11.98 years), posttreatment (T2; mean age, 15.32 years) and postretention (T3; mean age, 32.12 years) periods. All cephalometric radiographs were superimposed at the cranial base according to the overall superimposition methods of Björk, Ricketts, Steiner, and the T-W method. The horizontal and vertical displacements of cranial landmarks (nasion, wing, tuberculum sella, sella, basion, and pterygomaxillare) were assessed by paired t-test according to Björk's structural method. One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used for comparison of the displacement of cranial landmarks among the superimposition methods. Results: The tuberculum sella and wing were the most stable cranial landmarks of the cranial base. The stability of sella and pterygomaxillare pointswere somewhat questionable.Nasion and basionwere highly variable. The displacements of all cranial landmarks were similar between the Björk and T-W methods in all study periods.Most of the cranial landmarks displaced similarly in the horizontal direction among the methods. Vertically, the behaviors of the cranial landmarks were frequently different. Conclusions: T-W is the most similar superimposition method to Björk's structural method; thus, it is a reliable method for examining overall facial changes.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)725-732
Number of pages8
JournalAngle Orthodontist
Volume80
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 1 2010
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Skull Base
Puberty
Growth
Cephalometry
Analysis of Variance

Keywords

  • Cephalometrics
  • Cranial landmarks
  • Longitudinal growth
  • Superimposition methods

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Orthodontics

Cite this

Longitudinal growth changes of the cranial base from puberty to adulthood- A comparison of different superimposition methods. / Arat, Zuleyha Mirzen; Turkkahraman, Hakan; English, Jeryl D.; Gallerano, Ronald L.; Boley, Jim C.

In: Angle Orthodontist, Vol. 80, No. 4, 01.07.2010, p. 725-732.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Arat, Zuleyha Mirzen ; Turkkahraman, Hakan ; English, Jeryl D. ; Gallerano, Ronald L. ; Boley, Jim C. / Longitudinal growth changes of the cranial base from puberty to adulthood- A comparison of different superimposition methods. In: Angle Orthodontist. 2010 ; Vol. 80, No. 4. pp. 725-732.
@article{5ec72edff394427197c249b68bcd349a,
title = "Longitudinal growth changes of the cranial base from puberty to adulthood- A comparison of different superimposition methods",
abstract = "Objective: To investigate the stability of cranial reference landmarks from puberty through adulthood and to compare the displacement of these landmarks among the superimposition methods of Bj{\"o}rk, Ricketts, Steiner, and the proposed tuberculum sella-wing (T-W) reference line. Materials and Methods: The sample consisted of serial lateral cephalometric radiographs of 30 Class II division 1 patients taken at the pretreatment (T1; mean age, 11.98 years), posttreatment (T2; mean age, 15.32 years) and postretention (T3; mean age, 32.12 years) periods. All cephalometric radiographs were superimposed at the cranial base according to the overall superimposition methods of Bj{\"o}rk, Ricketts, Steiner, and the T-W method. The horizontal and vertical displacements of cranial landmarks (nasion, wing, tuberculum sella, sella, basion, and pterygomaxillare) were assessed by paired t-test according to Bj{\"o}rk's structural method. One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used for comparison of the displacement of cranial landmarks among the superimposition methods. Results: The tuberculum sella and wing were the most stable cranial landmarks of the cranial base. The stability of sella and pterygomaxillare pointswere somewhat questionable.Nasion and basionwere highly variable. The displacements of all cranial landmarks were similar between the Bj{\"o}rk and T-W methods in all study periods.Most of the cranial landmarks displaced similarly in the horizontal direction among the methods. Vertically, the behaviors of the cranial landmarks were frequently different. Conclusions: T-W is the most similar superimposition method to Bj{\"o}rk's structural method; thus, it is a reliable method for examining overall facial changes.",
keywords = "Cephalometrics, Cranial landmarks, Longitudinal growth, Superimposition methods",
author = "Arat, {Zuleyha Mirzen} and Hakan Turkkahraman and English, {Jeryl D.} and Gallerano, {Ronald L.} and Boley, {Jim C.}",
year = "2010",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.2319/080709-447.1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "80",
pages = "725--732",
journal = "Angle Orthodontist",
issn = "0003-3219",
publisher = "E H Angle Orthodontists Research & Education Foundation, Inc.",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Longitudinal growth changes of the cranial base from puberty to adulthood- A comparison of different superimposition methods

AU - Arat, Zuleyha Mirzen

AU - Turkkahraman, Hakan

AU - English, Jeryl D.

AU - Gallerano, Ronald L.

AU - Boley, Jim C.

PY - 2010/7/1

Y1 - 2010/7/1

N2 - Objective: To investigate the stability of cranial reference landmarks from puberty through adulthood and to compare the displacement of these landmarks among the superimposition methods of Björk, Ricketts, Steiner, and the proposed tuberculum sella-wing (T-W) reference line. Materials and Methods: The sample consisted of serial lateral cephalometric radiographs of 30 Class II division 1 patients taken at the pretreatment (T1; mean age, 11.98 years), posttreatment (T2; mean age, 15.32 years) and postretention (T3; mean age, 32.12 years) periods. All cephalometric radiographs were superimposed at the cranial base according to the overall superimposition methods of Björk, Ricketts, Steiner, and the T-W method. The horizontal and vertical displacements of cranial landmarks (nasion, wing, tuberculum sella, sella, basion, and pterygomaxillare) were assessed by paired t-test according to Björk's structural method. One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used for comparison of the displacement of cranial landmarks among the superimposition methods. Results: The tuberculum sella and wing were the most stable cranial landmarks of the cranial base. The stability of sella and pterygomaxillare pointswere somewhat questionable.Nasion and basionwere highly variable. The displacements of all cranial landmarks were similar between the Björk and T-W methods in all study periods.Most of the cranial landmarks displaced similarly in the horizontal direction among the methods. Vertically, the behaviors of the cranial landmarks were frequently different. Conclusions: T-W is the most similar superimposition method to Björk's structural method; thus, it is a reliable method for examining overall facial changes.

AB - Objective: To investigate the stability of cranial reference landmarks from puberty through adulthood and to compare the displacement of these landmarks among the superimposition methods of Björk, Ricketts, Steiner, and the proposed tuberculum sella-wing (T-W) reference line. Materials and Methods: The sample consisted of serial lateral cephalometric radiographs of 30 Class II division 1 patients taken at the pretreatment (T1; mean age, 11.98 years), posttreatment (T2; mean age, 15.32 years) and postretention (T3; mean age, 32.12 years) periods. All cephalometric radiographs were superimposed at the cranial base according to the overall superimposition methods of Björk, Ricketts, Steiner, and the T-W method. The horizontal and vertical displacements of cranial landmarks (nasion, wing, tuberculum sella, sella, basion, and pterygomaxillare) were assessed by paired t-test according to Björk's structural method. One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used for comparison of the displacement of cranial landmarks among the superimposition methods. Results: The tuberculum sella and wing were the most stable cranial landmarks of the cranial base. The stability of sella and pterygomaxillare pointswere somewhat questionable.Nasion and basionwere highly variable. The displacements of all cranial landmarks were similar between the Björk and T-W methods in all study periods.Most of the cranial landmarks displaced similarly in the horizontal direction among the methods. Vertically, the behaviors of the cranial landmarks were frequently different. Conclusions: T-W is the most similar superimposition method to Björk's structural method; thus, it is a reliable method for examining overall facial changes.

KW - Cephalometrics

KW - Cranial landmarks

KW - Longitudinal growth

KW - Superimposition methods

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77953191980&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=77953191980&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.2319/080709-447.1

DO - 10.2319/080709-447.1

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:77953191980

VL - 80

SP - 725

EP - 732

JO - Angle Orthodontist

JF - Angle Orthodontist

SN - 0003-3219

IS - 4

ER -