Nontraditional Surrogate Decision Makers for Hospitalized Older Adults

Amber R. Comer, James E. Slaven, Annie Montz, Emily Burke, Lev Inger, Alexia Torke

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: Without advanced preparation of legal documents, state law determines who may serve as a surrogate decision maker for patients in hospitals. Objectives: To examine the relationship characteristics associated with traditional versus nontraditional health care surrogates who are making medical decisions for patients in hospitals. Research Design: Secondary analysis of a baseline cross-sectional survey of a larger prospective observational study. Subjects: In total, 364 patient/surrogate dyads consisting of patients aged 65 years and older admitted to the medical or medical intensive care unit services who lacked decision-making capacity based on a physician assessment and also had a surrogate available. Results: This study of surrogate decision makers for hospitalized older adults found that the relationships of nontraditional surrogates such as, nieces, nephews, and friends serving in the surrogate role is nearly identical to those of traditional, first degree relatives serving as a surrogate. Over two-Thirds (71.2%) of nontraditional surrogates saw the patient in-person at least weekly compared with 80.8% of legal surrogates (P-value, 0.9023). Almost all traditional and nontraditional surrogates discussed the patient's medical preferences with the patient (96.9% of legal surrogates and 89.2% of nontraditional surrogates; P=0.0510). Conclusions: This study shows that both traditional and nontraditional surrogates, who are a patient's primary care giver have similar relationships with patients. The findings of this study suggest that requiring family members such as grandchildren to take the extra step of formal appointment through a legal channel may not be necessary to protect patients. Therefore, broader state laws expanding the list of surrogates authorized by state statute to include more nontraditional surrogates may be necessary.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)337-340
Number of pages4
JournalMedical Care
Volume56
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2018

Fingerprint

Patient Preference
Caregivers
Observational Studies
Intensive Care Units
Primary Health Care
Decision Making
Patient Care
Appointments and Schedules
Research Design
Cross-Sectional Studies
Prospective Studies
Delivery of Health Care
Physicians
Clinical Decision-Making

Keywords

  • health care decision making
  • informed consent
  • medical ethics
  • patient autonomy
  • surrogate decision making

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health

Cite this

Nontraditional Surrogate Decision Makers for Hospitalized Older Adults. / Comer, Amber R.; Slaven, James E.; Montz, Annie; Burke, Emily; Inger, Lev; Torke, Alexia.

In: Medical Care, Vol. 56, No. 4, 01.01.2018, p. 337-340.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Comer, AR, Slaven, JE, Montz, A, Burke, E, Inger, L & Torke, A 2018, 'Nontraditional Surrogate Decision Makers for Hospitalized Older Adults', Medical Care, vol. 56, no. 4, pp. 337-340. https://doi.org/10.1097/MLR.0000000000000890
Comer, Amber R. ; Slaven, James E. ; Montz, Annie ; Burke, Emily ; Inger, Lev ; Torke, Alexia. / Nontraditional Surrogate Decision Makers for Hospitalized Older Adults. In: Medical Care. 2018 ; Vol. 56, No. 4. pp. 337-340.
@article{0aac1b92b0354187bf62a77ff04e9cf4,
title = "Nontraditional Surrogate Decision Makers for Hospitalized Older Adults",
abstract = "Background: Without advanced preparation of legal documents, state law determines who may serve as a surrogate decision maker for patients in hospitals. Objectives: To examine the relationship characteristics associated with traditional versus nontraditional health care surrogates who are making medical decisions for patients in hospitals. Research Design: Secondary analysis of a baseline cross-sectional survey of a larger prospective observational study. Subjects: In total, 364 patient/surrogate dyads consisting of patients aged 65 years and older admitted to the medical or medical intensive care unit services who lacked decision-making capacity based on a physician assessment and also had a surrogate available. Results: This study of surrogate decision makers for hospitalized older adults found that the relationships of nontraditional surrogates such as, nieces, nephews, and friends serving in the surrogate role is nearly identical to those of traditional, first degree relatives serving as a surrogate. Over two-Thirds (71.2{\%}) of nontraditional surrogates saw the patient in-person at least weekly compared with 80.8{\%} of legal surrogates (P-value, 0.9023). Almost all traditional and nontraditional surrogates discussed the patient's medical preferences with the patient (96.9{\%} of legal surrogates and 89.2{\%} of nontraditional surrogates; P=0.0510). Conclusions: This study shows that both traditional and nontraditional surrogates, who are a patient's primary care giver have similar relationships with patients. The findings of this study suggest that requiring family members such as grandchildren to take the extra step of formal appointment through a legal channel may not be necessary to protect patients. Therefore, broader state laws expanding the list of surrogates authorized by state statute to include more nontraditional surrogates may be necessary.",
keywords = "health care decision making, informed consent, medical ethics, patient autonomy, surrogate decision making",
author = "Comer, {Amber R.} and Slaven, {James E.} and Annie Montz and Emily Burke and Lev Inger and Alexia Torke",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1097/MLR.0000000000000890",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "56",
pages = "337--340",
journal = "Medical Care",
issn = "0025-7079",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Nontraditional Surrogate Decision Makers for Hospitalized Older Adults

AU - Comer, Amber R.

AU - Slaven, James E.

AU - Montz, Annie

AU - Burke, Emily

AU - Inger, Lev

AU - Torke, Alexia

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - Background: Without advanced preparation of legal documents, state law determines who may serve as a surrogate decision maker for patients in hospitals. Objectives: To examine the relationship characteristics associated with traditional versus nontraditional health care surrogates who are making medical decisions for patients in hospitals. Research Design: Secondary analysis of a baseline cross-sectional survey of a larger prospective observational study. Subjects: In total, 364 patient/surrogate dyads consisting of patients aged 65 years and older admitted to the medical or medical intensive care unit services who lacked decision-making capacity based on a physician assessment and also had a surrogate available. Results: This study of surrogate decision makers for hospitalized older adults found that the relationships of nontraditional surrogates such as, nieces, nephews, and friends serving in the surrogate role is nearly identical to those of traditional, first degree relatives serving as a surrogate. Over two-Thirds (71.2%) of nontraditional surrogates saw the patient in-person at least weekly compared with 80.8% of legal surrogates (P-value, 0.9023). Almost all traditional and nontraditional surrogates discussed the patient's medical preferences with the patient (96.9% of legal surrogates and 89.2% of nontraditional surrogates; P=0.0510). Conclusions: This study shows that both traditional and nontraditional surrogates, who are a patient's primary care giver have similar relationships with patients. The findings of this study suggest that requiring family members such as grandchildren to take the extra step of formal appointment through a legal channel may not be necessary to protect patients. Therefore, broader state laws expanding the list of surrogates authorized by state statute to include more nontraditional surrogates may be necessary.

AB - Background: Without advanced preparation of legal documents, state law determines who may serve as a surrogate decision maker for patients in hospitals. Objectives: To examine the relationship characteristics associated with traditional versus nontraditional health care surrogates who are making medical decisions for patients in hospitals. Research Design: Secondary analysis of a baseline cross-sectional survey of a larger prospective observational study. Subjects: In total, 364 patient/surrogate dyads consisting of patients aged 65 years and older admitted to the medical or medical intensive care unit services who lacked decision-making capacity based on a physician assessment and also had a surrogate available. Results: This study of surrogate decision makers for hospitalized older adults found that the relationships of nontraditional surrogates such as, nieces, nephews, and friends serving in the surrogate role is nearly identical to those of traditional, first degree relatives serving as a surrogate. Over two-Thirds (71.2%) of nontraditional surrogates saw the patient in-person at least weekly compared with 80.8% of legal surrogates (P-value, 0.9023). Almost all traditional and nontraditional surrogates discussed the patient's medical preferences with the patient (96.9% of legal surrogates and 89.2% of nontraditional surrogates; P=0.0510). Conclusions: This study shows that both traditional and nontraditional surrogates, who are a patient's primary care giver have similar relationships with patients. The findings of this study suggest that requiring family members such as grandchildren to take the extra step of formal appointment through a legal channel may not be necessary to protect patients. Therefore, broader state laws expanding the list of surrogates authorized by state statute to include more nontraditional surrogates may be necessary.

KW - health care decision making

KW - informed consent

KW - medical ethics

KW - patient autonomy

KW - surrogate decision making

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85044712534&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85044712534&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1097/MLR.0000000000000890

DO - 10.1097/MLR.0000000000000890

M3 - Article

VL - 56

SP - 337

EP - 340

JO - Medical Care

JF - Medical Care

SN - 0025-7079

IS - 4

ER -