Privacy protectionism and health information: is there any redress for harms to health?

Judy Allen, C. D arcy J Holman, Eric M. Meslin, Fiona Stanley

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

9 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Health information collected by governments can be a valuable resource for researchers seeking to improve diagnostics, treatments and public health outcomes. Responsible use requires close attention to privacy concerns and to the ethical acceptability of using personal health information without explicit consent. Less well appreciated are the legal and ethical issues that are implicated when privacy protection is extended to the point where the potential benefits to the public from research are lost. Balancing these issues is a delicate matter for data custodians. This article examines the legal, ethical and structural context in which data custodians make decisions about the release of data for research. It considers the impact of those decisions on individuals. While there is strong protection against risks to privacy and multiple avenues of redress, there is no redress where harms result from a failure to release data for research.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationJournal of law and medicine
Pages473-485
Number of pages13
Volume21
Edition2
StatePublished - 2013

Fingerprint

protectionism
Privacy
health information
privacy
Health
health
Research
Personal Health Records
Ethics
Public Health
Research Personnel
diagnostic
public health
resources

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Health Policy
  • Issues, ethics and legal aspects
  • Law

Cite this

Allen, J., Holman, C. D. A. J., Meslin, E. M., & Stanley, F. (2013). Privacy protectionism and health information: is there any redress for harms to health? In Journal of law and medicine (2 ed., Vol. 21, pp. 473-485)

Privacy protectionism and health information : is there any redress for harms to health? / Allen, Judy; Holman, C. D arcy J; Meslin, Eric M.; Stanley, Fiona.

Journal of law and medicine. Vol. 21 2. ed. 2013. p. 473-485.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Allen, J, Holman, CDAJ, Meslin, EM & Stanley, F 2013, Privacy protectionism and health information: is there any redress for harms to health? in Journal of law and medicine. 2 edn, vol. 21, pp. 473-485.
Allen J, Holman CDAJ, Meslin EM, Stanley F. Privacy protectionism and health information: is there any redress for harms to health? In Journal of law and medicine. 2 ed. Vol. 21. 2013. p. 473-485
Allen, Judy ; Holman, C. D arcy J ; Meslin, Eric M. ; Stanley, Fiona. / Privacy protectionism and health information : is there any redress for harms to health?. Journal of law and medicine. Vol. 21 2. ed. 2013. pp. 473-485
@inbook{1005e8c14b124c37ac383aeeb29f96be,
title = "Privacy protectionism and health information: is there any redress for harms to health?",
abstract = "Health information collected by governments can be a valuable resource for researchers seeking to improve diagnostics, treatments and public health outcomes. Responsible use requires close attention to privacy concerns and to the ethical acceptability of using personal health information without explicit consent. Less well appreciated are the legal and ethical issues that are implicated when privacy protection is extended to the point where the potential benefits to the public from research are lost. Balancing these issues is a delicate matter for data custodians. This article examines the legal, ethical and structural context in which data custodians make decisions about the release of data for research. It considers the impact of those decisions on individuals. While there is strong protection against risks to privacy and multiple avenues of redress, there is no redress where harms result from a failure to release data for research.",
author = "Judy Allen and Holman, {C. D arcy J} and Meslin, {Eric M.} and Fiona Stanley",
year = "2013",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "473--485",
booktitle = "Journal of law and medicine",
edition = "2",

}

TY - CHAP

T1 - Privacy protectionism and health information

T2 - is there any redress for harms to health?

AU - Allen, Judy

AU - Holman, C. D arcy J

AU - Meslin, Eric M.

AU - Stanley, Fiona

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - Health information collected by governments can be a valuable resource for researchers seeking to improve diagnostics, treatments and public health outcomes. Responsible use requires close attention to privacy concerns and to the ethical acceptability of using personal health information without explicit consent. Less well appreciated are the legal and ethical issues that are implicated when privacy protection is extended to the point where the potential benefits to the public from research are lost. Balancing these issues is a delicate matter for data custodians. This article examines the legal, ethical and structural context in which data custodians make decisions about the release of data for research. It considers the impact of those decisions on individuals. While there is strong protection against risks to privacy and multiple avenues of redress, there is no redress where harms result from a failure to release data for research.

AB - Health information collected by governments can be a valuable resource for researchers seeking to improve diagnostics, treatments and public health outcomes. Responsible use requires close attention to privacy concerns and to the ethical acceptability of using personal health information without explicit consent. Less well appreciated are the legal and ethical issues that are implicated when privacy protection is extended to the point where the potential benefits to the public from research are lost. Balancing these issues is a delicate matter for data custodians. This article examines the legal, ethical and structural context in which data custodians make decisions about the release of data for research. It considers the impact of those decisions on individuals. While there is strong protection against risks to privacy and multiple avenues of redress, there is no redress where harms result from a failure to release data for research.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84897578458&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84897578458&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Chapter

C2 - 24597394

AN - SCOPUS:84897578458

VL - 21

SP - 473

EP - 485

BT - Journal of law and medicine

ER -