Toothpastes and enamel erosion/abrasion – Impact of active ingredients and the particulate fraction

C. Ganss, J. Marten, Anderson Hara, N. Schlueter

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

11 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objectives To investigate in vitro a range of differently characterised toothpastes with respect to their efficacy in an erosion/abrasion setting with special emphasis on the role of the particulate ingredients. Methods Human enamel samples were erosively demineralised with citric acid (2 min, 6×/day; 0.5%, pH 2.5; 10 days) and immersed in slurries (2 min, 2×/day) either without or with brushing (15 s, load 200 g). The toothpastes were eight NaF-toothpastes, three hydroxyapatite-toothpastes (one without and two with NaF), one fluoride-free chitosan-toothpaste and three Sn-toothpastes. Negative control was erosion only, positive control was SnF2 gel. Tissue loss was quantified profilometrically. Results The SnF2 gel was most effective (reduction of tissue loss of 79%). Most of the products reduced tissue loss significantly when applied as slurries (between 28 and 66%). Brushing increased tissue loss in almost all toothpastes, only 5 formulations (all Sn-toothpastes and 2 NaF-toothpastes) reduced tissue loss significantly when compared to negative control (between 33 and 59%). There was a non-linear association between abrasiveness and amount of particles in a formulation, the particle size had no impact. Conclusions Toothpastes had a protecting effect when applied as slurries but to a much lesser degree when applied with brushing. The particulate fraction may be a determinant for toothpaste efficacy in erosion/abrasion settings. Clinical significance Toothpastes are important carriers of active agents against erosion, but physical impacts through brushing modifies efficacy distinctly. Understanding the role of the particulate fraction in toothpastes may offer perspectives for designing effective formulations for patients with erosive lesions.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)62-67
Number of pages6
JournalJournal of Dentistry
Volume54
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2016

Fingerprint

Toothpastes
Dental Enamel
Gels
Chitosan
Durapatite
Fluorides
Particle Size
Citric Acid

Keywords

  • Abrasion
  • Abrasives
  • Enamel
  • Erosion
  • Toothbrushing
  • Toothpaste

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Dentistry(all)

Cite this

Toothpastes and enamel erosion/abrasion – Impact of active ingredients and the particulate fraction. / Ganss, C.; Marten, J.; Hara, Anderson; Schlueter, N.

In: Journal of Dentistry, Vol. 54, 01.01.2016, p. 62-67.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{41fc4722b03a48268688c3c2718b5810,
title = "Toothpastes and enamel erosion/abrasion – Impact of active ingredients and the particulate fraction",
abstract = "Objectives To investigate in vitro a range of differently characterised toothpastes with respect to their efficacy in an erosion/abrasion setting with special emphasis on the role of the particulate ingredients. Methods Human enamel samples were erosively demineralised with citric acid (2 min, 6×/day; 0.5{\%}, pH 2.5; 10 days) and immersed in slurries (2 min, 2×/day) either without or with brushing (15 s, load 200 g). The toothpastes were eight NaF-toothpastes, three hydroxyapatite-toothpastes (one without and two with NaF), one fluoride-free chitosan-toothpaste and three Sn-toothpastes. Negative control was erosion only, positive control was SnF2 gel. Tissue loss was quantified profilometrically. Results The SnF2 gel was most effective (reduction of tissue loss of 79{\%}). Most of the products reduced tissue loss significantly when applied as slurries (between 28 and 66{\%}). Brushing increased tissue loss in almost all toothpastes, only 5 formulations (all Sn-toothpastes and 2 NaF-toothpastes) reduced tissue loss significantly when compared to negative control (between 33 and 59{\%}). There was a non-linear association between abrasiveness and amount of particles in a formulation, the particle size had no impact. Conclusions Toothpastes had a protecting effect when applied as slurries but to a much lesser degree when applied with brushing. The particulate fraction may be a determinant for toothpaste efficacy in erosion/abrasion settings. Clinical significance Toothpastes are important carriers of active agents against erosion, but physical impacts through brushing modifies efficacy distinctly. Understanding the role of the particulate fraction in toothpastes may offer perspectives for designing effective formulations for patients with erosive lesions.",
keywords = "Abrasion, Abrasives, Enamel, Erosion, Toothbrushing, Toothpaste",
author = "C. Ganss and J. Marten and Anderson Hara and N. Schlueter",
year = "2016",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.jdent.2016.09.005",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "54",
pages = "62--67",
journal = "Journal of Dentistry",
issn = "0300-5712",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Toothpastes and enamel erosion/abrasion – Impact of active ingredients and the particulate fraction

AU - Ganss, C.

AU - Marten, J.

AU - Hara, Anderson

AU - Schlueter, N.

PY - 2016/1/1

Y1 - 2016/1/1

N2 - Objectives To investigate in vitro a range of differently characterised toothpastes with respect to their efficacy in an erosion/abrasion setting with special emphasis on the role of the particulate ingredients. Methods Human enamel samples were erosively demineralised with citric acid (2 min, 6×/day; 0.5%, pH 2.5; 10 days) and immersed in slurries (2 min, 2×/day) either without or with brushing (15 s, load 200 g). The toothpastes were eight NaF-toothpastes, three hydroxyapatite-toothpastes (one without and two with NaF), one fluoride-free chitosan-toothpaste and three Sn-toothpastes. Negative control was erosion only, positive control was SnF2 gel. Tissue loss was quantified profilometrically. Results The SnF2 gel was most effective (reduction of tissue loss of 79%). Most of the products reduced tissue loss significantly when applied as slurries (between 28 and 66%). Brushing increased tissue loss in almost all toothpastes, only 5 formulations (all Sn-toothpastes and 2 NaF-toothpastes) reduced tissue loss significantly when compared to negative control (between 33 and 59%). There was a non-linear association between abrasiveness and amount of particles in a formulation, the particle size had no impact. Conclusions Toothpastes had a protecting effect when applied as slurries but to a much lesser degree when applied with brushing. The particulate fraction may be a determinant for toothpaste efficacy in erosion/abrasion settings. Clinical significance Toothpastes are important carriers of active agents against erosion, but physical impacts through brushing modifies efficacy distinctly. Understanding the role of the particulate fraction in toothpastes may offer perspectives for designing effective formulations for patients with erosive lesions.

AB - Objectives To investigate in vitro a range of differently characterised toothpastes with respect to their efficacy in an erosion/abrasion setting with special emphasis on the role of the particulate ingredients. Methods Human enamel samples were erosively demineralised with citric acid (2 min, 6×/day; 0.5%, pH 2.5; 10 days) and immersed in slurries (2 min, 2×/day) either without or with brushing (15 s, load 200 g). The toothpastes were eight NaF-toothpastes, three hydroxyapatite-toothpastes (one without and two with NaF), one fluoride-free chitosan-toothpaste and three Sn-toothpastes. Negative control was erosion only, positive control was SnF2 gel. Tissue loss was quantified profilometrically. Results The SnF2 gel was most effective (reduction of tissue loss of 79%). Most of the products reduced tissue loss significantly when applied as slurries (between 28 and 66%). Brushing increased tissue loss in almost all toothpastes, only 5 formulations (all Sn-toothpastes and 2 NaF-toothpastes) reduced tissue loss significantly when compared to negative control (between 33 and 59%). There was a non-linear association between abrasiveness and amount of particles in a formulation, the particle size had no impact. Conclusions Toothpastes had a protecting effect when applied as slurries but to a much lesser degree when applied with brushing. The particulate fraction may be a determinant for toothpaste efficacy in erosion/abrasion settings. Clinical significance Toothpastes are important carriers of active agents against erosion, but physical impacts through brushing modifies efficacy distinctly. Understanding the role of the particulate fraction in toothpastes may offer perspectives for designing effective formulations for patients with erosive lesions.

KW - Abrasion

KW - Abrasives

KW - Enamel

KW - Erosion

KW - Toothbrushing

KW - Toothpaste

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84994846016&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84994846016&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jdent.2016.09.005

DO - 10.1016/j.jdent.2016.09.005

M3 - Article

C2 - 27650640

AN - SCOPUS:84994846016

VL - 54

SP - 62

EP - 67

JO - Journal of Dentistry

JF - Journal of Dentistry

SN - 0300-5712

ER -